SharonSenate64ConstitutionalityCitySt.PaulTenantRemedys

                          CONSTITUTIONAL CHALLENGE REQUEST4MNAG OPINION

           SEPARATION POWERS https://www.leg.state.mn.us/docs/2003/mandated/030343.pdf

Ord 20-14

4

17

Ordinance

Creating Chapter 193 of the Legislative Code (Title XIX) pertaining to Tenant Protections.

https://www.ag.state.mn.us/Consumer/Handbooks/LT/CH3.asp

                        PLEASE NOTE CALIFORNIA CASE Sub City Council St. PAUL,MN

Blogger: User Profile: Sharon4Anderson
Christensen v. California Judicial Council | Pacific Legal Foundation

Christensen-v.-California-Judicial-Council-Petition-for-Peremptory-Writ-of-Mandate.pdf
by issuing 11 emergency rules of court. Among these was Emergency Rule 1 (“ER 1”), which violates the fundamental rights of property owners by indefinitely suspending their right to initiate unlawful detainer actions. The rule creates the perverse incentive for all tenants, whether they face financial hardship or not, to refuse to pay their rent during the crisis. And it immunizes from eviction even tenants who create nuisances, damage property, conduct illegal activity, or violate lease terms. ER 1’s restrictions not only visit significant hardship on landlords like Petitioners; they are also unconstitutional. 

• Government cannot deprive landlords of their right to evict tenants who are able to pay rent yet refuse to do so, crippling their businesses and handicapping their ability to help tenants who face financial hardship.
• The California Constitution’s separation of powers prevents government agencies like the California Judicial Council from overriding the legislature and governor to take the law into its own hands and make social policy.

In a message dated 6/19/2020 4:54:37 AM Central Standard Time, sharon4anderson@aol.com writes:

                                            NO STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS ON FRAUD OR MURDER WHAT YOU PEOPLE DID TO PETTIFORD FAMILY DYING OF KIDNEY FAILURE TAKING HIS HOME AT 603 EDMOND IS UNFORGIVABLE.   

                                    FRI.19Jun2020  TO THE ABOVE NAMED; Specifically Clerk Shari Moore, Senate 64 Candidates Sharon,Erin, Patricia. Note to Patricia to Legal Marijuana for the Blind as Sharons

Blindness exploited by DFL THE PARTY of Hatred, Dispair,Disparity

                               Ruling Case USSC 10-1032 tITLED Magner vs Gallagher

                              Citys Dirty Deals  https://www.nationalbcc.org/images/stories/DOJ-St-Paul.pdf

The effects of sacrificing Newell’s case will cost American taxpayers the opportunity to recover up to $200 million and allow St.

      NO STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS ON FRAUD OR MURDER WHAT YOU PEOPLE DID TO PETTIFORD FAMILY DYING OF KIDNEY FAILURE TAKING HIS HOME AT 603 EDMOND IS UNFORGIVABLE.   

                                    FRI.19Jun2020  TO THE ABOVE NAMED; Specifically Clerk Shari Moore, Senate 64 Candidates Sharon,Erin, Patricia. Note to Patricia to Legal Marijuana for the Blind as Sharons

Blindness exploited by DFL THE PARTY of Hatred, Dispair,Disparity

                               Ruling Case USSC 10-1032 tITLED Magner vs Gallagher

                              Citys Dirty Deals  https://www.nationalbcc.org/images/stories/DOJ-St-Paul.pdf

The effects of sacrificing Newell’s case will cost American taxpayers the opportunity to recover up to $200 million and allow St. Paul’s misdeeds to go unpunished. Far more troubling, however,

Far more troubling, however, is the fundamental damage that this quid pro quo has done to the rule of law in the United States and to the reputation of the Department of Justice as a fair and impartial arbiter of justice.

 

                        Please note Affiant Sharon4usa Property owner state and alleges that Erin Murphy the DFL edorse 4 Gov, got dumped by Current Gov Tim Waltz and Muslin MNAG Keith Ellison.DFL CHAIR TOM PEREZ.

                        Erin would have made a better Governor However This Current City Ordinance Tenant Remedys is subject to Fail if Passed.

                       HOWEVER when City Council DFL ENDORSE Erin Murphy 

                            puts all Litigants,Republicans at Risk for Fair Impartial hearings,Comments

 

                       Please read Sharons Chamber Response http://sharonsenate64.blogspot.com

 

Sharon Learned about Law and Computers. Exposing Government Misconduct re QuiTam Relator.e. Her professional experience includes being a political activist.^[1]

​​SAFETY: We pledge to make public safety ,Ethics in government . Fair Housing,Realestate Equity Skimming,Quiet Titles,
Magner v. Gallagher

No. 10-1032 In the Supreme Court of the United States STEVE MAGNER, ET AL., PETITIONERS v. THOMAS J. GALLAGHER, ET AL

                                                  QUESTIONS PRESENTED

                        1. Whether disparate-impact claims are cognizable under Section 804(a) of the Fair Housing Act, 42 U.S.C. 3604(a). 2. Whether the court of appeals correctly applied a burden-shifting framework in analyzing respondents’ disparate-impact claims.

6/24/2020

10:00 AM

Council Chambers - 3rd Floor Remote public hearing for Ord 20-14

Meeting details

Agenda

Ord 20-14

4

17

Ordinance

Creating Chapter 193 of the Legislative Code (Title XIX) pertaining to Tenant Protections.

 

Creating Chapter 193 of the Legislative Code (Title XIX) pertaining to Tenant Protections.

Sponsors:

Mitra Jalali, Jane L. Prince, Nelsie Yang, Rebecca Noecker, Amy Brendmoen

Attachments:

1. Hyperlink to Register to Speak at 10:00 am Public Hearing, 2. Alliance - Equity in Place letter, 3. HREEO Comission Letter, 4. Teamsters Local 120 Letter, 5. Refusal to renew Amendment, 6. Substantially equivalent Amendment, 7. Real Estate Equities Letter, 8. SPRLF Tenant Protection Ordinance letter, 9. SP350 letter, 10. Online Comment, 11. PHA letter, 12. MICAH letter, 13. Comment 1 rec'd by Council, 14. HOME Line letter, 15. Payne Phalen CC Letter, 16. Twin Cities Habitat for Humanity letter, 17. SPAAR Letter, 18. Union Park DC Letter 6.4.20, 19. Catholic Charities - SAFE Ordinance Public Comments 06.05.20, 20. MN HIV Housing Coalition letter, 21. Ord 20-14 Version 3, 22. Housing Justice Center Letter, 23. ISAIAH Housing Letter_061220, 24. St Anthony Park CC Letter, 25. St. Paul Federation of Educators Letter, 26. Radius Health letter, 27. Version 4 Amendments, 28. Noecker Amendment, 29. Jalali Amendment, 30. Thao - Tenant Protections Amendments, 31. Prince Amendment, 32. Summary of Tenant Protections Amendments 6-12-20, 33. SPPS Project REACH letter, 34. MCCD Letter, 35. D1 Letter, 36. SPAAR Letter 2, 37. Presentation_Fair Housing_Tenant Protections_6-17-2020a, 38. SAFE HOUSING SAINT PAUL (002), 39. Comment 2 rec'd by Council

122 Comments 

 

6/18/2020 10:02 AM

SharonSen64

Against

What a Waste of Cable Time Confusing Amendments, Renters Mita and Nelsie huge Conflicts,City's override State and Federal Constitutions re USSC 10-1032 titled Magner vs. Gallagher Dirty Dealings http://sharangel.blogspot.com Further each and every Comments must be shown on the Screen on Cable 18 This is another TRASH issue

The St. Paul City PO Box 4656, Saint Paul, MN 55104 | info@murphyfor64.com

Council will hold a virtual public hearing on Wednesday, June 24 at 10:00 am for Ord 20-14 Creating Chapter 193 of the Legislative Code pertaining to Tenant Protections. Information on how to participate in this meeting is located as the first attachment on the agenda item or here.  The link on the
Who’s running

Senate District 64  re
Peter Callaghan | MinnPost

• Incumbent: Richard Cohen DFL NOT RUNNING
• From: St. Paul
• First elected: 1
  Candidate Filings986

Candidates

• Sharon Anderson R [Website]
• PO Box 4656, Saint Paul, MN 55104 | info@murphyfor64.com
• 
  Legal Marijunia Party LMN - Google Search
• Patricia McArdell LMN  
• 
  Supporters — Erin Murphy | Candidate for MN Senate - 64
• Erin Murphy DFL [Website]  

for the Minnesota Legislature in 2020 | MinnPostagenda 

 

 

 

2020 Elections: Protected or Infected?

The League of Women Voters St. Paul (LWVSP), with support from the St. Paul Neighborhood Network, presents "2020 Elections: Protected or Infected?” a free program on Tuesday, June 30, 6:30pm - 8:00pm. 

 

will be removed at 12:00 pm on Tuesday, June 23.
Erin Murphy for State Senate - Home

Erin Murphy: Now is Our Moment.

 

In a message dated 6/16/2020 2:20:02 PM Central Standard Time, sharon4anderson@aol.com writes:

 

         AFFIANT SharonScarrellaAnderson Current Candidate

                    http://sharonsenate64.blogspot.com Forensic Files http://sharangel.blogspot.com  

                              On the graves of her parents Tenants in Common till Death

Do us Part, will Continue to expose http://citystpaul-ponzi-principal.blogspot.com 

xx

Sharon Anderson aka Scarrella 651-776-5835 sharon4anderson@aol.com

http://blogitbabe.blogspot.com    http://sharon4council.blogspot.com

LEGAL NOTICE: /s/Sharon4Anderson@aol.com ECF_P165913Pacersa1299 telfx: 651-776-5835:
Attorney ProSe_InFact,Private Attorney General QuiTam Whistleblower, www.taxthemax.blogspot.com 
The Electronic Communications Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C. 
Ch.119 Sections 2510-2521 et seq., governs distribution of this "Message," 
including attachments, may contain the originator's
proprietary information. The originator hereby notifies
recipients Message review, dissemination, copying, and content-based 
actions. Authorized carriers of this message 
shall expeditiously deliver this Message to intended recipients.  See: Quon 
v. Arch

AG Barr Calls OUT SOROS4CausincreaseCrimeElections,HousingofStateAG

                             Tues24Dec2019 Christmas Eve  Open Letter to Mr. President Donny Dearest.

                                          send your letter to Trump Tower in Manhattan at 725 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10022.  Washington, D.C.1717 Pennsylvania Avenue NW, Washington, DC 20006

                                            Bravo Standing Ovation and        Thanks Mr. President Donald Trump 2020 4 Bringing Christmas back to the American People and ME aka Widow,White,Whistleblower MRS. Sharon Anderson aka Peterson,1st Husband John Scarrella, We are not Liars or Lawyers. BOMBSHELL! AG Barr Calls Out Soros for Causing “Increase in Violent Crime and More Victims” By Targeting District Attorney Elections

    On the Graves of our Heritage, Affiant re Penalty of Perjury state and allege the following;

                                             The Problems DFL Current Nat.Chair  Obama Lawyer Tom Perez who Quo Warranto and Quid Pro Quo made Secret Deals with City St. Paul, Lawyer David Lillhaug and Sara Grewing both now Justice and 2nd Judicial Judge.

    https://www.nationalbcc.org/images/stories/DOJ-St-Paul.pdf

THE QUID PRO QUO EXPLAINED.......................................................................................... 17 The Agreement Was a Quid Pro Quo Exchange .................................................................... 18 Assistant Attorney General Perez Facilitated the Initial Stages of the Quid Pro Quo ........... 21 The Initial Stages of the Quid Pro Quo Confused and Frustrated Career Attorneys ............. 23 HUD’s Purported Reasons for Its Changed Recommendation in Newell Are Unpersuasive and a Pretext for HUD’s Desired Withdrawal of Magner...................................................... 26 The “Consensus” that Emerged for Declining Intervention in Newell Directly Resulted from Assistant Attorney General Perez’s Stewardship of the Quid Pro Quo......................... 31 As Discussions Stalled, Assistant Attorney General Perez Took the Lead and Personall
HUD Sued for Records of Obama Administration Involvement in Controversial St. Paul, MN, Housing Discrimination Case | Judicial Watch

                  Sharons Search takes the 4  DFL Sanctuary State's Examples apparantly either directly or indirectly forcing Sharia Law to undermine USA Constitutions State and Federal.

sharon4council.blogspot.com

                 Sharons Senior MOMENT is the Zinger of a Remote Control spilled Tea, did not work, Ordered another, after 3 days Remote worked. will keep the New one just in Case.
Scoop (news) - Wikipedia

                   Politics,Police,Pelosi Poo similar to Poker-Joker,Pool 8 Ball,

                                 

                 Sharons Mentor Bill Windsor at http://lawlessamerica.com and

                   *
SharonsFreedomLawSchool

                  Michael Volpe at
Blogger: Posts

DirtyJudgesStateMN2019RESandraGrazziniRucki

Sharon4Anderson

                                    THEREFORE; William Barr's investigations approved by the American People to Keep America Alive,Safe,Strong vs Foreign Terriorists, Domestic and George Soros Money.

                      MINNESOTA,California,Michigan,Illinois. State AG MN - Google Search

                        Home | The Office of Attorney General Keith Ellison

www.ag.state.mn.us state ag california - Google SearchXavier Becerra state ag Michigan - Google Search

                                      Dana Nessel is an American lawyer and politician serving as the 54th Attorney General of Michigan. She is a member of the Democratic Party. Nessel is the second openly gay person elected attorney general of a state in the United States as well as the first oay,lesbian.   and

Illinois Attorney General Home Page  

        Attorney General Kwame Raoul was sworn in as the 42nd Attorney General of Illinois in January 2019. Raoul was born in Chicago to Haitian immigrants and brings a lifetime of legal and policy experience, advocacy, and public service to the Office of the Attorney General.

 
Trump WRECKS Pelosi In Open Letter - Freedom Wire 

Sharon4Anderson

Sharon4MNAG

Attorney General William Barr has warned that liberal billionaire George Soros has been bankrolling radical prosecutor candidates in cities across the country.
In an interview that aired Friday on "The Story," Barr said that the Hungarian-American activist is likely relying on the routinely low turnout in local primary elections to help his candidates win.
"There's this recent development [where] George Soros has been coming in, in largely Democratic primaries where there has not been much voter turnout and putting in a lot of money to elect people who are not very supportive of law enforcement and don't view the office as bringing to trial and prosecuting criminals but pursuing other social agendas," Barr told Martha MacCallum.
"They have started to win in a number of cities and they have, in my view, not given the proper support to the police."

GEORGE SOROS SCORES WINS IN VIRGINIA ELECTIONS, AS OPPONENTS SAY RACE WAS 'BOUGHT' 

Dr. Richard Cordero, Esq.Ph.D., University of Cambridge, England
M.B.A., University of Michigan Business School
D.E.A., La Sorbonne, Paris
Judicial Discipline ReformNew York City
http://www.Judicial-Discipline-Reform.org
Dr.Richard.Cordero_Esq@verizon.net , DrRCordero@Judicial-Discipline-Reform.org , CorderoRic@yahoo.com
Judicial Discipline Reform – A study of judges' unaccountability and consequent riskless wrongdoing; how to expose it and bring about judicial reform

Sharon Anderson aka Scarrella 651-776-5835 Currently Doggie Hospice with Rescue Dogs, Aging,Blindness etc. sharon4anderson@aol.com

http://blogitbabe.blogspot.com    http://sharon4council.blogspot.com

LEGAL NOTICE: /s/Sharon4Anderson@aol.com ECF_P165913Pacersa1299 telfx: 651-776-5835:
Attorney ProSe_InFact,Private Attorney General QuiTam Whistleblower, www.taxthemax.blogspot.com 
The Electronic Communications Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C.
Ch.119 Sections 2510-2521 et seq., governs distribution of this "Message,"
including attachments, may contain the originator's
proprietary information. The originator hereby notifies
recipients Message review, dissemination, copying, and content-based
actions. Authorized carriers of this message
shall expeditiously deliver this Message to intended recipients.  See: Quon
v. Arch

LandLordsvsCitySt.Paul,MNUSSC10-1032TITLEDMagnervsGallagher2012DismissedviaFraudbyTomPerez,DavidLillhaug,SaraGrewing,ChrisColeman

Tom Perez made RICO Deals

DOJ-St-Paul.pd

        Sun.3Mar2019        lEGAL NOTICE TO PUBLIC 
fTHAT FRAUD OCCURRED 
             Current DFL Nat.Chair Tom Perez, who committed Fraud vs. USA, Perez former Asst.AG, then Hud Commissioner, current DFL Chair has lied to Congress and the Citizens of St. Paul,MN, ACTING IN CONCORT with VChair Muslin Keith Ellison now MNAG.
           THESE BAMA BOYS MUSLINS ELLISON/PEREZ HAVE AND ARE COMMITTING CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY.  http://crimes-against-humanity.blogspot.com 

DflChairTomPerezformerUSAG,HUD,labor 

Muslin Kassimi Busuri appt St.Paul Council2019

Doug Wardlow exposing Muslin Keith Ellison now MNAG 

Executive Summary In early February 2012, Assistant Attorney General Thomas E. Perez made a secret deal behind closed doors with St. Paul, Minnesota,
                      Mayor Christopher Coleman and St. Paul’s outside counsel, David Lillehaug. Perez agreed to commit the Department of Justice to declining intervention in a False Claims Act qui tam complaint filed by whistleblower Fredrick Newell against the City of St. Paul, as well as a second qui tam complaint pending against the City, in exchange for the City’s commitment to withdraw its appeal in Magner v. Gallagher from the Supreme Court
                          , an appeal involving the validity of disparate impact claims under the Fair Housing Act. Perez sought, facilitated, and consummated this deal because he feared that the Court would find disparate impact unsupported by the text of the Fair Housing Act. Calling disparate impact theory the “lynchpin” of civil rights enforcement, Perez simply could not allow the Court to rule. Perez sought leverage to stop the City from pressing its appeal. His search led him to David Lillehaug and then to Newell’s lawsuit against the City. Fredrick Newell, a minister and small-business owner in St. Paul, had spent almost a decade working to improve economic opportunities for low-income residents in his community. In 2009, Newell filed a whistleblower lawsuit alleging that the City of St. Paul had received tens of millions of dollars of community development funds, including stimulus funding, by improperly certifying its compliance with federal law. By November 2011, Newell had spent over two years discussing his case with career attorneys in the Department of Housing and Urban Development, the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Minnesota, and the Civil Fraud Section within the Justice Department’s Civil Division. These three entities, which had each invested a substantial amount of time and resources into Newell’s case, regarded this as a strong case potentially worth as much as $200 million for taxpayers and recommended that the federal government join the suit. These career attorneys even went so far as to prepare a formal memorandum recommending intervention, calling St. Paul’s actions a “particularly egregious example of false certifications.” All this work was for naught. In late November 2011, Lillehaug made Perez aware of Newell’s pending case against the City and the possibility that the Justice Department may intervene. A trade was proposed: non-intervention in Newell’s case for the withdrawal of Magner. Perez contacted HUD General Counsel Helen Kanovsky and asked her to reconsider HUD’s support for intervention in Newell’s case. Perez also spoke to then-Civil Division Assistant Attorney General Tony West and B. Todd Jones, the U.S. Attorney for the District of Minnesota, alerting them to his new interest in Newell’s case. The withdrawal of HUD’s support for Newell’s case led to an erosion of support in the Civil Division, a process that was actively managed by Perez. In January 2012, Perez began leading negotiations with Lillehaug, offering him a “roadmap” to a global settlement. Once negotiations appeared to break down, Perez boarded a plane and flew to Minnesota to meet face-to-face with Mayor Coleman. At that early February meeting, Perez pleaded for the fate of disparate impact and reiterated the Justice Department’s willingness to strike a deal. His lobbying paid off when Lillehaug accepted the deal on Mayor 

Magner v. Gallagher

Docket No.	Op. Below	Argument	Opinion	Vote	Author	Term
10-1032	8th Cir.	Not Argued	Feb 14, 2012	N/A	N/A	OT 2011

Disclosure: Goldstein & Russell, P.C. serves as counsel to the respondents in this case.

Issue: (1) Whether disparate impact claims are cognizable under the Fair Housing Act; and, if so (2) what test should be used to analyze them.

Plain English Issue: (1) Whether a lawsuit can be brought for a violation of the Fair Housing Act based on a practice that is not discriminatory on its own, but has a discriminatory effect; and, if so, (2) how should courts determine whether a practice has a discriminatory effect and violates the Act?

Judgment: Dismissed - Rule 14 on February 14, 2012.

SCOTUSblog Coverage

• Fair housing case dismissed (Lyle Denniston)
• Petition of the day (Conor McEvily)

Briefs and Documents

Merits Briefs for the Petitioners

• Brief for Steve Magner et al.

Amicus Briefs in Support of the Petitioners

• Brief of the International Municipal Lawyers Association et al.
• Brief of the Township of Mount Holly, New Jersey
• Brief of the Pacific Legal Foundation et al.
• Brief of the Independent Community Bankers of America et al.
• Brief of the Eagle Forum Education & Legal Defense Fund, Inc.
• Brief of the American Bankers Association et al. 

Amicus Briefs in Support of Neither Party

• Brief of the United States

Merits Briefs for the Respondents

• Brief of Thomas Gallagher et al.

Amicus Briefs in Support of the Respondents

• Brief of the NAACP Legal Defense & Education Fund
• Brief of the Lawyer’s Committee on Civil Rights et al. 
• Brief of the Housing Advocates, Inc., and Buckeye Community Hope Foundation
• Brief of the National Fair Housing Alliance et al. 
• Brief of the Opportunity Agenda et al. 
• Brief of the ACLU
• Brief of Massachusetts et al.
• Brief of Henry G. Cisneros
• Brief of AARP and Mount Holly Gardens Citizens In Action

Certiorari-stage documents

• Opinion below (8th Cir.)
• Petition for certiorari
• Brief in opposition of respondents Thomas J. Gallagher et al.



SharonMayoralCandidateChrisColeman ex;posing USSC 10-1032



Julian Assaugne exposint DFL Chair Tom Perez


• Petitioners' reply